We make things that work better and last longer. Our products solve real problems with clean design and honest materials.
Skip to results list

Filters

162 items
Price
to
The highest price is $379.95
Brand

Filter

Price
to
The highest price is $379.95
Brand

Looking to enhance intimacy, intensify orgasms, or explore new sensations? A body-safe butt plug is your essential tool for anal pleasure. Designed for extended wear rather than thrusting, a butt plug offers a unique feeling of fullness that stimulates sensitive nerve endings and can lead to deeper, more powerful climaxes. At Hush, our collection is carefully curated to prioritize your safety and comfort, featuring ergonomically shaped butt plugs made from premium silicone, smooth glass, and weighted stainless steel.

For those new to anal play, a beginner butt plug gently helps the body relax and acclimate to sensation. For the experienced, it can be the key to achieving prostate orgasms (for people with prostates) or blended orgasms, and a staple for kink and role-play. Its versatility makes it perfect for solo exploration or to add a thrilling new dimension to partnered sex.

Why Choose a Butt Plug? Key Benefits Explained
  • Amplify Orgasms: The constant, gentle pressure from a worn plug stimulates a dense network of nerve endings. This can dramatically intensify vaginal, penile, or prostate orgasms during other sexual activities.
  • Safe Preparation: Using a progressively sized plug is the recommended method to safely stretch and relax the anal muscles, preparing your body for anal sex or larger toys with confidence and minimal discomfort.
  • Discreet Extended Wear: Designed with a secure, flared base, many plugs are comfortable for discreet wear under clothing, offering a constant, private tease or enhancing arousal throughout the day.
  • Versatile Scenarios: A cornerstone toy for double penetration, sensory play, BDSM scenes, and adding profound fullness to any sexual encounter.

Choosing the right plug, selecting the correct size, shape, and material, is the foundation of a positive and pleasurable experience. Let our guide below help you find your perfect match.

How to Choose Your Perfect Butt Plug: A Safety & Sensation Guide

Selecting the right butt plug is about matching size, material, and shape to your experience level and desired sensation. Follow this guide to ensure a safe, comfortable, and profoundly pleasurable experience.

The #1 Rule: The Flared Base is Non-Negotiable

Every safe anal plug must have a wide, flared base or a secure retrieval loop. This design prevents the toy from being fully absorbed by the body, ensuring easy and safe removal. It is the fundamental safety feature that distinguishes a butt plug from other insertables.

Choose by Material: Feel & Function

The material defines the toy's sensation, weight, and care routine.

  • Body-Safe Silicone (Our Top Recommendation):Feel: Soft, flexible, and slightly yielding. Warms to body temperature.
    Benefits: Hypoallergenic, non-porous for easy cleaning, perfect for beginners. Ideal for long-term wear due to comfort.
    Best For: Almost everyone, especially first-time users and those seeking comfort.
  • Tempered Glass or Stainless Steel:Feel: Firm, smooth, and substantial. Retains temperature (for temperature play).
    Benefits: Delivers a unique feeling of weighted fullness, incredibly smooth glide, and is completely body-safe.
    Best For: Experienced users, temperature play, and those who enjoy a distinct sense of pressure and heft.
  • Jewel-Tipped Plugs (with a silicone or metal base):Feel: Typically a silicone or metal stem with a decorative gem or stone base.
    Benefits: Adds an aesthetic, visually appealing element to play. The flat, gemstone base can be more comfortable for extended wear than a round base.
    Best For: Discreet wear, adding a visual spark, and role-play scenarios.

Choose by Size: Start Small, Progress Smartly

For Beginners: Always start with a small butt plug. Look for a "starter kit" with multiple sizes or a plug with a slender neck and a maximum diameter of no more than 1 inch (2.5 cm). The goal is gentle acclimation.
For Experienced Users: You can explore medium to large plugs, weighted plugs for intense fullness, or inflatable plugs for adjustable size. Progress gradually to avoid discomfort.

Choose by Shape: Comfort is Key

  • Tapered Tip: A gradual, slim tip for easy, gentle insertion.
  • Slender Neck: A thinner section behind the bulb makes the plug more comfortable for extended wear and easier to retain.
  • Ergonomic Base: A T-bar base often fits more comfortably between the cheeks for long-term wear than a round base.

Ready to Explore? Use these guidelines as your checklist. Below, browse our curated collection of body-safe butt plugs, where each product is selected with your safety and satisfaction as the priority.

Butt Plug FAQs:
How do I choose the right size butt plug?

Choosing the correct butt plug size is essential for comfort, safety, and enjoyment, especially if you’re new to anal play. Beginners should always start with a small butt plug featuring a slim, tapered tip, as this allows the body to relax gradually during insertion.

Many beginner butt plugs have an insertable length similar to a finger, making them ideal for first-time use. Once you feel comfortable, you can progress to larger sizes for a deeper sense of fullness and more intense sensations.

If you enjoy exploring at your own pace, anal training kits are a great option, as they include multiple sizes to help you advance safely and confidently.
What materials are safest for butt plugs?

The safest butt plugs are made from high-quality, body-safe, non-porous materials. These materials do not absorb bacteria, making them hygienic, easy to clean, and suitable for regular anal play.

The most recommended butt plug materials include:

  • Body-safe silicone – soft, flexible, and ideal for beginners
  • Stainless steel – smooth, weighty, and excellent for pressure and temperature play
  • Glass (Pyrex) – ultra-smooth, non-porous, and visually elegant

Silicone butt plugs are especially popular for beginners due to their gentle flexibility, which allows for easier insertion. Glass and stainless steel butt plugs are favoured by experienced users who enjoy firmness, weight, and temperature play (warming or cooling sensations).
Can beginners use vibrating butt plugs?

Yes, vibrating butt plugs are safe and enjoyable for beginners, provided you choose a smaller size and start on a low vibration setting.

Vibration can help relax the anal muscles during insertion and enhance overall pleasure by stimulating sensitive nerve endings. Compared to non-vibrating butt plugs, vibrating options offer adjustable intensity levels, making them suitable for both new and experienced users.

For partnered play, vibrating butt plugs can increase sensation for both partners during penetration. For solo play, especially for men, vibration can help stimulate the prostate more effectively, often leading to stronger orgasms. Some vibrating butt plugs even feature remote control or app control, allowing hands-free pleasure and playful interaction with a partner.
Are butt plugs for men and women?

Absolutely. Butt plugs are designed for everyone, regardless of gender or experience level.

For men, butt plugs are an excellent introduction to prostate stimulation, often referred to as the male G-spot. For women, butt plug use can create indirect stimulation of the G-spot and A-spot through the vaginal wall, which may intensify orgasms during solo or partnered play.

Butt plugs are also commonly used by couples to enhance intimacy, add variety to foreplay, or combine anal stimulation with other sex toys.
How do I properly insert and remove a butt plug?

Safe and comfortable butt plug use comes down to two essential rules: go slow and use plenty of lubricant.

Because the anus does not self-lubricate, always apply a generous amount of water-based or anal-specific lubricant to the butt plug and the surrounding area before insertion. Insert slowly, pause when needed, and never force the toy. Mild pressure is normal, but pain is not.

For removal, relax your body and gently pull the plug out at a slow, controlled pace. If you feel resistance, apply more lubricant and bear down slightly, similar to using the bathroom. Taking your time ensures a smooth and comfortable experience.

👉 For best results, pair your toy with a high-quality option from our Lubricants Collection.
What are the safety precautions for extended butt plug wear?

If you plan to wear a butt plug for an extended period, whether at home or discreetly under clothing, taking the right precautions is crucial.

Start with a smaller butt plug, even if you’re experienced with larger sizes during sex. Limit wear time initially and gradually increase duration as your body adapts. Always use a plug made from body-safe materials and ensure it is thoroughly cleaned before and after use.

Listen closely to your body. If you experience numbness, pain, or discomfort, remove the plug immediately. Keep lubricant accessible and reapply as needed, especially during longer wear sessions.